Xindian Eviction Case Illustrates Recurrent Dynamics

by Brian Hioe

語言:
English
Photo Credit: Heeheemalu/WikiCommons/CC BY-SA 4.0

A FORCED EVICTION case in Xindian has drawn concern from Taiwanese civil society, with long-term residents of a historic structure possibly forced to vacate it in the near future.

In particular, the eviction case revolves around the Tsai Jin-mu house, which has been inhabited by the Lai family for eighty years and was built by their grandfather, Tsai Jin-mu. The Lai family previously sought to seek cultural preservation status for the structure, as an example of architecture that dated to the Japanese colonial period. However, this was denied by the Cultural Bureau of the New Taipei City government in June, which concluded that the bricks used in the structure are similar in size to those that date from the Japanese colonial period, but that this could not prove that the structure indeed dated from then.

Other structures in the neighborhood have already been demolished, starting from 2006, because of the construction of the Liugong Canal. Nevertheless, the Lai family was unexpectedly sued in 2014, demanding the return of the land, having found out that the Irrigation Association had sold the land in 2012 to a developer for a low price without notifying. Although the Lai family had expressed a desire to purchase the land 60 years prior, at the time, the Irrigation Association had claimed that the land was government property that was hard to deal with.

Consequently, litigation over the property has been ongoing for over a decade. Though the Lai family has housing plates and taxation documents, and the house had a household registration and allowed for the payment of utility bills and taxes, the Lai family has lost many of the lawsuits it filed over the land. Among the justifications for the rulings were not filing applications for the land, though previously the Lai family had been ruled to have the rights to apply for the land.

In 2021, the Control Yuan published a report stating that the Irrigation Association had treated the land as unused in its auction process, which was procedurally incorrect. Experts on land use in Taiwan have highlighted the case as one that touches on issues of transitional justice, given that the dispute over the property rights stems from the various historical transitions Taiwan saw in the 20th century. Likewise, the International Tribunal on Evictions has raised concerns about the case.

The residents of the home have been successful in securing stays of demolition in the past. Nevertheless, it is possible that the Tsai Jin-mu House will prove to be a case similar to when other communities were forced out of their homes in Taipei, with examples in the past decade including the Huaguang Community and Daguan Community. Though the Lai family has hosted screenings and otherwise linked with Taiwanese civil society groups, there is not as much attention to cases of forced urban evictions as there was in the years prior to the Sunflower Movement, even with a KMT mayoral administration in charge of New Taipei. What comes next remains to be seen.